West Ham's celebrated academy has produced no shortage of transfer fees this summer — just not much in the way of first-team careers to show for it. Freddie Potts, Callum Marshall, Krisztian Hegyi and Andy Irving have all left the building in 2026, and the pattern behind their exits stretches back much further than this one transfer window.
Potts is the most eye-catching departure. Officially confirmed this week after 16 years at the club, the academy graduate has joined Belgium side Club Brugge on a permanent deal worth around £10.2 million. He was supposed to be the second coming of Declan Rice. However, he made just 28 senior appearances for West Ham despite a contract running to 2029, a Wycombe Wanderers loan that earned him League One Player of the Year, and a place in the squad that won the Europa Conference League in Prague back in 2023. Marshall, meanwhile, has been sent to Luton Town after failing to force his way past the likes of Pablo Felipe.
Hegyi and Irving both ended up at the same club: Sparta Prague, co-owned by West Ham's own Daniel Křetínský. Hegyi joined permanently in June after seven years in the academy system without ever making a senior first-team appearance. 90-plus outings for the youth sides and a handful of matchday squad inclusions were as close as he got. Irving's route was different; he'd actually made his Premier League debut for West Ham in February 2025, but by January 2026 he'd been sold to Sparta for around €1.5 million. Two academy products ending up at the same overseas club owned by a West Ham shareholder feels suspicious.
None of this is new. Grady Diangana's £18 million sale to West Brom in 2020 is probably the clearest marker of how long this has been going on. It even got former captain and now West Ham executive Mark Noble angry. He made his feelings known publicly by posting that he was "gutted, angry and sad that Grady has left," a tweet liked by a young Declan Rice. Academy coach Carlton Cole later admitted the call came down to business rather than football logic, saying simply that "there are money situations that can't be neglected." Diangana never established himself in the Premier League afterwards.
He's far from alone. Ben Johnson spent 17 years at the club, made 109 senior appearances, played through the Europa League semi-final run and started eight games in the 2023 Conference League triumph, then left on a free transfer to Ipswich in 2024 after turning down an improved five-year offer. Ipswich, now promoted to the Premier League, but Johnson is mostly a second or third option fullback. Harrison Ashby made his top-flight debut as a substitute against Arsenal before being sold to Newcastle for around £3m in 2023. He now also plays for Luton Town in League One. Sonny Perkins beat Cole Palmer, Alejandro Garnacho and Crysencio Summerville to a Premier League 2 Player of the Month award in 2022, only to be sold to Leeds within months and spend the years since drifting through League One with Oxford, Leyton Orient and Wigan. Conor Coventry was sold to Charlton. Divin Mubama left on a free transfer the same week as Johnson in 2024, another forward who never cracked a top-flight senior squad.
They all can’t be Declan Rice
What links almost all of these names is that none of them became what West Ham fans actually wanted from their academy: a genuine, sustained top-flight regular. Declan Rice remains the one recent name who did — captaining the club, winning a European trophy, and eventually leaving for a British-record fee at Arsenal. Everyone else on this list has either failed to nail down a Premier League career elsewhere or, like Hegyi, never even got the chance to prove it at West Ham in the first place.
That track record cuts both ways in how this summer's exits should be read. On one hand, it's another year of academy graduates leaving before truly being given their shot, continuing a trend fans have complained about for half a decade. On the other, the club can reasonably point out that the money has, historically, held up better than the alumni. Very few of the departures have gone on to become the player West Ham's supporters hoped they'd be. Whether Potts, Marshall or anyone else breaks that trend elsewhere remains to be seen. Based on recent history, the smart money belongs to West Ham.
Add us as a preferred source on Google